Partner Disclosure: Free kit / Get Free Kit links are provided through our partner Augusta Precious Metals. Competitor company pages are for comparison and review only.
Natalie Ford
Written and reviewed by Natalie Ford, Research Editor
Our comparison of precious metals IRA companies draws on public information and criteria we set ourselves.
Last reviewed: October 2026 — Next review: January 2027
Tax accuracy reviewed by: Natalie Ford, Research Editor, March 2026. Primary sources: IRS Pub. 590-A, IRC §408, CFPB Complaint Database (Feb 2026), BBB Business Profiles. Methodology: Fee transparency (30%), BBB/CFPB outcomes (25%), IRS compliance (25%), buyback competitiveness (20%). Full methodology
Affiliate Disclosure: This site earns referral fees from some companies listed. Compensation does not influence rankings or scores. Rankings are based on independent research conducted February–March 2026 using BBB Business Profiles (bbb.org), CFPB Consumer Complaint Database (consumerfinance.gov), company-published fee schedules, and Trustpilot verified review counts.
Investment Risk Disclosure: Precious metals IRAs involve risk of loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This content does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Consult a registered investment advisor and tax professional before making retirement account decisions.
Expert Gold IRA Analysis & Reviews Updated Nov 2026

Goldco Review

★★★★★ 4.8/5

Goldco ranks second on this site with a 4.8/5 rating and a $25,000 minimum. The page below focuses on what Goldco does best, the buyback and the rollover paperwork, and on the phone-based process you should be comfortable with before you start.

Get Free Kit → Visit Goldco
Minimum $25,000
BBB Rating A+
Experience 16+ Years
Highlight Full-Service Leader

✔ Pros

  • The home page puts the buyback at 1-2% below spot, the tightest spread it cites
  • Four metals are available: gold, silver, platinum and palladium
  • Goldco handles the rollover paperwork with your existing plan administrator
  • The home-page review names Equity Trust and Kingdom Trust as custodians
  • A+ BBB rating shown in this site's comparison table

✖ Cons

  • The process runs mainly by phone, with limited digital options
  • Education is a secondary focus compared with Augusta
  • Rollover time is quoted as 7-10 days here and 7-14 business days on the home page

What the buyback means in dollars

The home page says Goldco buys metal back at roughly 1-2% below spot. That spread is the cost of leaving, and it is easy to turn into dollars: on a $30,000 sale a 1% spread costs $300 and a 2% spread costs $600. A dealer that buys back 4% below spot would cost $1,200 on the same sale.

Treat the figure as a question, not a promise. Ask Goldco to confirm in writing how the buyback price is set, whether the same spread applies to coins and bars, and how many business days pass between the sale and the cash arriving in the IRA.

How a Goldco rollover runs

Goldco's selling point on this site is that its staff handle the rollover paperwork and coordinate with your current plan administrator. The sequence is the standard one for any self-directed IRA.

  • Open the self-directed IRA with a custodian; the home-page review names Equity Trust and Kingdom Trust.
  • Sign the transfer forms. The new custodian contacts your old 401(k) or IRA administrator.
  • Funds move by direct trustee-to-trustee transfer, which avoids the 60-day rule and the 20% withholding on an indirect rollover.
  • Once the money arrives, you pick IRS-eligible metals and the custodian pays for the order.
  • The metal ships to an approved depository and is stored in your IRA's name.

Goldco costs on this page

The fee figures stored on this page are estimates, and the home-page review quotes different numbers for some lines, so the only figures that count are the ones in the company's written fee schedule. The home page lists a $50 setup fee and $175-225 a year for storage and custodian fees combined, which is one more reason to ask for a single written total.

Fee TypeCost
Minimum $25,000
Setup ~$50
Annual ~$80
Storage $100-175/year

Red flags to watch for on the phone

Goldco's process is conversation-heavy, so the risk sits in what is said and not written. Pressure to decide within a day, a push toward collectible or numismatic coins, and any promise about future gold prices are all reasons to stop. IRS rules limit IRA metal to bullion that meets the fineness minimums: 99.5% for gold, 99.9% for silver and 99.95% for platinum and palladium.

Verify the claims independently. Read the company's BBB profile and complaints, search the CFPB database, and ask for the bid and ask prices in an email.

Where Goldco fits among the five

With a $25,000 minimum Goldco sits in the middle of the field: below Augusta's $50,000, above Noble Gold's $20,000 and well above the $10,000 entry at American Hartford Gold and the $5,000 entry at Birch Gold Group. Its edge on this site is the buyback spread and the hands-off paperwork. Birch Gold Group and Augusta put more weight on education, so an investor who wants to read first and call later may prefer them.

Our Verdict

Goldco suits rollover investors with $25,000 or more who are comfortable on the phone and care about the exit price. Get the buyback terms and the first-year fee total in writing before you transfer.

Get Free Kit →

Goldco FAQ

Goldco's minimum is $25,000 according to this site's comparison table.

This site quotes 7-10 days on this page and 7-14 business days on the home page. The real timing depends on how fast your old plan administrator releases the funds, so ask for the steps and dates.

The home page cites roughly 1-2% below spot. Ask Goldco to confirm the figure and the payout time in writing.

The site lists gold, silver, platinum and palladium. Each metal must meet the IRS fineness minimum to qualify for an IRA.

Disclosure: Some featured companies may pay us a referral fee. Our order of companies reflects BBB ratings, fees, customer reviews and editorial judgment, not payment. The material here is educational and is not financial advice.